Martha's Country Bakery Forest Hills Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Martha's Country Bakery Forest Hills, a delightful haven for dessert lovers located at 70-28 Austin St, Forest Hills, NY. This bakery is renowned for its extensive selection of cakes, pastries, and pies, making it a must-visit spot for anyone with a sweet tooth.
The menu offers tempting cake slices, each priced at $7.50, including classic favorites like Red Velvet and Tiramisu. For pie aficionados, whole pies like the Triple Berry Pie and Sour Cream Apple Pie are available, perfect for sharing or indulging solo. Not to miss is their Berry Napoleon pastry, praised for its crisp layers and creamy filling.
Customer reviews rave about the exceptional quality and cozy atmosphere, despite occasional long lines. Whether you're looking for a quick treat or a place to linger with friends, Martha's offers an inviting experience that will leave you craving more.
Whole Pies Cake Slices Pastries Slice of Pie Sliced Cheesecake Vegan Sliced Cakes Fruit Tarts Pudding French Macaroons Mini Mousse Cakes Cake Pops Mediteranean Pastries Chewy Cookie Cup Cakes Large Cookie Assorted Bars Creme Brulee Mini Tarts Bundt and Crumbs Yogurt Pound Cake Muffins Breakfast Pastries Pie
Whole Pies
Old Fashion Apple Pie
$26.00
Apple Crumb Pie
$26.00
Sour Cream Apple Pie
$26.00
Mississippi Mud Pie
contains nuts
$26.00
Blueberry Pie
$27.00
Cherry Pie
$27.00
Triple Berry Pie
$27.00
Key Lime Pie
$26.00
Pecan Pie
$28.00
Pumpkin Pie
$28.00
Apple Strudel
$21.00
Chocolate Layer Cake Slice
$7.50
Chocolate Mousse Cake Slice
$7.50
Chocolate Fudge Cake Slice
$7.50
Strawberry Banana Cake Slice
$7.50
Strawberry Shortcake Cake Slice
$7.50
Triple Chocolate Mousse Cake Slice
$7.50
Red Velvet Cake Slice
$7.50
Carrot Cake Slice
contains nuts
$7.50
Tiramisu Cake Slice
$7.50
Caramel Mousse Cake Slice
$7.50
Oreo Mousse Cake Slice
$7.50
7 Layer Cake Slice
$7.50
Black Forest Cake Slice
$7.50
Tres Leche Cake Slice
$7.50
Cake Slices
Pastries
Blondie
contains nuts
$5.95
Brownie-Walnut
$4.00
Cannoli
$4.95
Eclair
$4.95
Custard Napoleon
$5.50
Berry Napoleon
$7.75
Old Fashion Apple Pie Slice
$7.25
Sour Cream Apple Pie Slice
$6.95
Mississippi Mud Pie Slice
contains nuts
$7.25
Cherry Pie Slice
$7.25
Apple Strudel Pie Slice
$7.25
Apple Crumb Pie Slice
$7.25
Triple Berry Pie Slice
$7.25
Blueberry Pie Slice
$7.25
Pecan Pie Slice
$7.25
Cranberry Walnut Pierre Slice
$7.25
Slice of Pie
Sliced Cheesecake
New York Style Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Black Forest Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Raspberry Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Brownie-Walnut Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Strawberry Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Apple Crumb Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Oreo Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Marble Cheesecake Slice
$7.50
Vegan and Gluten Free Carrot Cake Slice
contains nuts
$8.25
Vegan and Gluten Free Choc Fudge Cake Slice
$8.25
Vegan Strawberry Cheesecake Cake Slice
$8.00
Vegan Sliced Cakes
Fruit Tarts
Mixed Fruit Tart
$22.00
Banana Pudding
$5.95
Rice Pudding
$5.95
Bread Pudding
$6.50
Banana Chocolate Chip Bread
$6.50
Flan
$7.25
Pudding
French Macaroons
Vanilla Macaroon
$3.25
Chocolate Macaroon
$3.25
Hazelnut Macaroon
$3.25
Strawberry Macaroon
$3.25
Passsion Fruit Macaroon
$2.95
Tiramisu Macaroon
$3.25
Nutella Macaroon
$3.25
Lemon Macaroon
$3.25
Raspberry Macaroon
$3.25
Pistachio Macaroon
$3.25
Mini Coconut Mousse Cake
$7.25
Mini Raspberry Mousse Cake
$7.25
Mini Passion Fruit Mousse Cake
$7.25
Mini Hazelnut Mousse Cake
$7.50
Mini Mousse Cakes
Cake Pops
Chocolate Cake Pop
$3.50
Red Velvet Cake Pop
$3.50
Oreo Cake Pop
$3.50
Baklava
contains nuts
$6.25
Galaktobouriko
$5.95
Mediteranean Pastries
Chewy Cookie
Chocolate Chunk Chewy Cookie
$4.25
Peanut Butter Chewy Cookie
$4.25
Heath Bar Chewy Cookie
$4.25
Macadamia Nut Chewy Cookie
$4.25
Oatmeal Raisin Chewy Cookie
$4.25
Party Chewy Cookie
$4.25
Vanilla Vanilla Cup Cake
$3.25
Vanilla Chocolate Cup Cake
$3.25
Chocolate Chocolate Cup Cake
$3.25
Chocolate Vanilla Cup Cake
$3.25
Black Forest Cup Cake
$3.25
Cappuccino Cup Cake
$3.25
Hazelnut Cup Cake
$3.25
Vanilla White Chocolate Ganache Cup Cake
$3.25
Chocolate Chocolate Ganache Cup Cake
$3.25
Red Velvet Cup Cake
$3.25
Oreo Cup Cake
$3.25
Lemon Berry Cup Cake
$3.25
Carrot Cup Cake
$3.25
Strawberry Cup Cake
$3.25
Party Cup Cake
$3.25
Peanut Butter Cup Cake
$3.25
Tiramisu Cup Cake
$3.25
Cup Cakes
Large Cookie
Almond Horn Plain Large Cookie
$3.95
Almond Horn Choc Dipped Large Cookie
$3.95
Black and White Large Cookie
$4.25
Linzar Tart Large Cookie
$4.00
Raspberry Macaroon Tart Large Cookie
$3.95
Apricot Macaroon Tart Large Cookie
$3.95
Apricot Hamantash Large Cookie
$3.95
Prune Hamantash Large Cookie
$3.75
Raspberry Hamantash Large Cookie
$3.95
Salted Chocolate Caramel Walnut Cheesecake Bar
$5.95
Pecan Caramel Cheesecake Bar
$5.95
Key Lime Cheesecake Bar
$5.95
Assorted Bars
Creme Brulee
Crme Brule
$7.50
Banana Nutella Crme Brulee
$7.95
Mixed Berry Mini Tart
$7.25
Mixed Fruit Mini Tart
$7.25
Mini Tarts
Bundt and Crumbs
Marble Bundt
$12.95
Blueberry Bundt
$12.95
Cranberry Crumb Yogurt Pound Cake
$3.95
Blueberry Banana Yogurt Pound Cake
$3.95
Banana Walnut Yogurt Pound Cake
$3.95
Vanilla Yogurt Pound Cake
$3.95
Lemon Poppy Yogurt Pound Cake
$3.95
Marble Yogurt Pound Cake
$3.95
Whole Pound Cake Loaf
$8.50
Yogurt Pound Cake
Muffins
Apple Crumb Muffin
$3.95
Blueberry Muffin
$3.95
Cranberry Muffin
$3.95
Cappuccino Muffin
$3.95
Sugar Free Blueberry Muffin
$3.95
Sugar Free Cranberry Muffin
$3.95
Corn Muffin
$3.95
Bran Muffin
$3.95
Carrot Muffin
$3.95
Banana Walnut Muffin
$3.95
Lemon Poppy Muffin
$3.95
Chocolate Muffin
$3.95
Apple Turnover
$3.95
Sugar Free Apple Turnover
Folded and stuffed pastry dough.
$3.95
Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
$3.95
Choc. Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
$3.95
Cinnamon Danish
Flaky pastry with a sweet filling.
$3.95
Cheese Danish
Flaky pastry with a sweet filling.
$3.95
Almond Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
$3.95
Chocolate Stick
$3.95
Cinnamon Stick
$3.95
Palmier Plain
$3.95
Palmier Chocolate Dipped
$3.95
Blueberry-Cheese Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
$3.95
Strawberry-Cheese Croissant
A flaky French pastry.
$3.95
Breakfast Pastries
Pie
Savory Spinach Pie
$6.75